Where this happens, it is claimed, the child is given the violent message that violence is wrong. If children fear their teachers, they are unlikely to ask questions or challenge views that their teachers present to them. Corporal punishment in american education (philadelphia temple university press, 1979). People and violence in south africa (cape town oxford university press, 1990), pp. Some might suggest, for example, that girls ought to be treated more gently than boys because girls have a more delicate constitution.
It is well known that often minority groups and especially males receive a disproportionate share of corporal punishment. It is a reductio because this conclusion is absurd Buy now Essay About Corporal Punishment
I am well aware that the responsibility for childrens wrongdoing is all too often placed exclusively at the door of children themselves, without due attention to the influences to which they are subjected. However, there is a danger that in rejecting this incorrect evaluation, teachers (and parents) will be blamed for all shortcomings in children. On a retributivist theory, for any punishment to be just it must be inflicted only on guilty parties and then only in proportion to the wrongdoing. However, if this is the concern, surely the fitting response would be to place limitations on the use of the punishment and, at least in schools, to monitor and enforce compliance. However, if children are punished for genuine wrongdoing -- lying, cheating, stealing, bullying -- then the message is that this behavior is unacceptable Essay About Corporal Punishment Buy now
Teachers who regularly and severely hit pupils are feared, not respected (though characteristically such teachers are unable to distinguish between the two). However, i think that an unease about corporal punishment is perfectly compatible with my theoretical position. It is true that corporal punishment involves the application of direct and intense power to the body, but i do not see how that constitutes a more severe lowering of somebodys standing than employing indirect and mild power in the course of a strip-search, for example. There are some significant differences between the home and school settings. The chances of having suicidal thoughts, according to this study, decreases marginally with one incident of corporal punishment during adolescence, then rises slightly for three to five episodes of corporal punishment Buy Essay About Corporal Punishment at a discount
In the case of very young children i am inclined to agree. However, there is already some evidence of the deterrent effect of corporal punishment, at least with very young children. I am aware that medical examinations are necessary in a way in which corporal punishment is not, but corporal punishment might nonetheless fulfill an important function. Thus it is perceived as exacerbating the very problems from which it arises. However, i cannot discount the possibility that some will think that gender differences are relevant.
They are then required to fetch the detained child at a later time, which may be inconvenient. Utilitarians are also concerned about punishing only the guilty and in proportion to wrongdoing, even if their concern about these conditions is merely instrumental and so theoretically overridable Buy Online Essay About Corporal Punishment
An overview of american school (and college) paddling in the present and the recent past, with relevant documents, pictures and external links. The study is not specifically about corporal punishment. The detention may well cause the hardship, but that is quite different from punishing it. Some positive arguments for this form of punishment were also raised. Can you send me a full information pack as soon as possible? Although this website contains mainly factual material, expressions of argument and opinion also have their place, provided they are clearly labelled as such.
What do the entries in friends reunited tell us about corporal punishment in uk schools in the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s? Includes a top fifty cp schools feature based on the number of mentions of cp for each school Buy Essay About Corporal Punishment Online at a discount
The index then rises five points for nineteen instances of corporal punishment. I have argued that the objections to mild and infrequent corporal punishment fail because there is insufficient evidence for their premises. It is these arguments that lie behind the adage violence breeds violence. Straus, beating the devil out of them, chap. In other versions, only one party -- usually but not always the beater -- may experience sexual excitement through the beating.
But, of course, we do not punish the family. Given that even the data suggesting that very rare instances of mild corporal punishment do have some negative effects also suggest that the effects are not substantial, there is a strong likelihood that they could be overridden by other considerations in a consequentialist calculation Essay About Corporal Punishment For Sale
The increments on his mean symptoms index of depression are only slight for one or two instances of corporal punishment during ones teen years. Contrary to the views of those who oppose all physical punishment, it is not implausible to think that such punishment, if inflicted under the appropriate conditions, might do some good. To establish this, much more research needs to be done. Although there is evidence that excessive corporal punishment can significantly increase the chances of such psychological harm, most of the psychological data are woefully inadequate to the task of demonstrating that mild and infrequent corporal punishment has such consequences. There are now about 1,800 of these handbook links, covering australia (1), bahamas (2), barbados (5), ghana (7), grenada (1), kenya (2), malaysia (9), nigeria (3), northern mariana islands (2), pakistan (2), philippines (2), singapore (106), south africa (3), tanzania (1), zambia (2), zimbabwe (4) and the usa (about 1,600) For Sale Essay About Corporal Punishment
People and violence in south africa (cape town oxford university press, 1990), pp. Equally punishing boys and girls undermines rather than perpetuates gender stereotypes. Study of an experiment at a high school in georgia, usa, where paddling was reintroduced, for minor infractions, but purely as an option freely chosen by the student instead of detention or in-school suspension. Some might suggest, for example, that girls ought to be treated more gently than boys because girls have a more delicate constitution. A punishment might have some deterrent effect without being extremely effective.
I cannot see any reason for thinking that infrequent and mild corporal punishment would be likely to have any of these effects Sale Essay About Corporal Punishment